he's been improving with his lute playing skills

Come back after 10 minutes or so. He won't improve if you wait there. When he's really good, he will give you a love song.

ohhh. i noticed his fee has increased too.

Yup, you'll know if he's masterd the instrument when you can no longer find him at the town square

it's been 10 minutes plus... he's still there

Go do something else lol You need to leave Sedona. Do whatever is next in your journal till then.

the next on my journal is "use the stone of aya to mel and.... " which is I think the last quest. I think if I fulfill that I can't go back to claim the love song.

Yeah that's correct, you won't be able to go back after that. Are you sure you re-entered the city after waiting 10 mins gametime?

I think that last step may be longer than 10 minutes.

It's 10 minutes, but you need to leave Sedona. If you just hang around in the city or go to the castle, it won't happen. You need to enter Sedona via Riven Forest after the 10 minutes is up.

Okay, I think I already know the answer, but if I did not pick up enough of the items while on the Arishta Isles, I can't go get those items after I've gone to Thais? I love Lydia, but she doesn't deserve to marry Edward. Or to get out of jail, for that matter. XD

Not able to.Try to marry with the one which you can,except Lydia! -.- Otherwise,poor Edward. XD

Lydia's the only one I can marry. -.-

Well, you can still marry Belf...
At least it's a better option compared to Lydia. lol

When I finished the game I just had 2 gifts and could only marry Lydia and Belf too, so now I'm replaying it!

First of all, how do you get the money to buy the rings? I can't find anything but 1000 gold from the chest in Lydia's room, and I can't open all of the chests (I never got the first picklock). And then, does anyone have a save file with the items needed for Mel? I want the good ending, but I can't get it. D=

Try searching the gold in red chests inside Thais castle

I can't. I tried to get the first picklock after Mel had taken all of the royals. Therefore, I couldn't get the magic picklock. I take it the Belf ending is the only one I can use... -.-

There are a few chests in the castle (check all the rooms) and a couple outside the castle.

I guess I just have to replay it. I just hate how I finished the game, but I still didn't get the real ending. D:

Oh!!! I understand now. They're not magically-locked. They're just red. 0.o

Can be opened without the pick lock,just search for them all around.