And all of them are needed.I got the comb,the cupcake and the snail first time.Really,they are the easiest to get,and not very miss-able.
All the possible gifts are:
Cupcake
Comb
Poem
Snail
And not the last,Wedding Ring with favorite color.

Just wondering.
Where were the poem and comb?

Comb is in Mysten Far,lying on ground. XD As for poem,Reveries?

Help the writer in Sedona to get a lute and then give it to the beggar there. Come back after 10 mins to hear him play. When he's mastered the instrument, he'll give you a love song.

You can find the comb on the ground in Mysten Far.

I skipped the poem,really,too much fuss with it.The first three gifts listed are the easiest to get of all.

Thanks! Definitely something to do when I replay

No problem.Ask anytime for help.Usually the lurkers on this part of the forum instant reply,so you'll always get help. XP

The wedding ring is not one of the gifts, though it is needed for proposing. The 5th gift is the bouquet of lilies.

And not all are needed. You need 4 for Mel's approval.

I got the purple ring but Mel says she's not ready to get married. What should i do now?

Across the whole game there are certain objects that you collect and can give to Mel at the end as gifts to make her more attracted to Edward. This thread might help;

http://www.amaranthia.com/modules/new ... p?topic_id=15543&forum=88

I have the correct ring, bouquet,comb and the snail but it isn't enough.

Where is the cupcake?

For the poem the little men is asking money 10 but no poem I tried for 15 time or more and nothing happened.

So the step I need to move on with the plot is to find the wedding ring in Sedona. I'm stuck. Can someone help me?

There's a gem dealer there somewhere. Check all the shops.

The cupcake is in Velderah, you have to attend the little girl's party to get it.

The cupcake you get from going to a birthday party in Veldarah.

The love song you have to leave the city for ten minutes.

After the second time he won't be in front of the castle, but inside it. That is when he'll give you the love song.

Thanks , I found it after some careful prodding around. Does buying the lucky amulet first drop the price a little?

Nope. It's a set price. You shouldn't have a hard time getting the amount of gold though.

Alright, thanks very much

I got the love song but what about the cupcake i went to Veldarah but i haven't seen any house with a birthday party. Where is the b-day party located in veldarah???

You have to do a quest to activate the birthday party.


Look for a group of kids playing. Well three playing, one standing still.