Amaranth Games Forum Index >
The Plaza
> Village Square (Gossip and Chat)
> Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone
Browsing this Thread:
1 Anonymous Users
| Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #1 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
Over Sea, Under Stone was written by Susan Cooperand is part of The Dark Is Rising Sequence of books.
If you enjoyed reading Over Sea, Under Stone perhaps you'll enjoy the other Dark Is Rising books: The Dark is Rising (book 2) Greenwitch (book 3) The Grey King (book 4) Silver on the Tree (book 5) Is there a movie based on the set of books? Yes. It's called The Seeker and was made in 2007. PLOT: The Drew children Simon, Jane, and Barney find an old map in a hidden room while summering at the Grey House in Cornwall. Along with their Great-Uncle Merry, they become embroiled in a web of intrigue that surrounds an Arthurian legend. (taken from Amazon.com) ![]() Ready for the Discussion, but don't know where to begin? Try answering one of these questions. Also if you answered the poll, please tell us why you made the selection you did. Discussion Starters If you quote the book please put the book excerpt in quotation marks and post the page number. *Did you like Over Sea, Under Stone? Why or Why not? *What is your favorite part of Over Sea, Under Stone? Why? *Who is your favorite character? Why? *What character do you most relate to? and Why? *Do you plan to read the rest of the series? Why or Why not? *If you were one of the children, and found the manuscript, would you have taken it to your parents?...left it alone?... or tried to unlock the mystery? A Note From Lady Twilight *If you think of more discussion starter questions please PM them to me and I will add them to this post* *Sorry for the delay in starting this discussion I had some RL things come up, my apologies* *You do not have to be a Book Club member to take part in this discussion. However, if you would like to join the book club and recieve updates via PM please let us know in the book club thread.
Posted on: 2008/9/2 14:14
|
|||||||||||
| Re: Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #2 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
where is everyone?
anyway, my fav char was simon
Posted on: 2008/9/4 2:08
|
|||||||||||
| Re: Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #3 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
It's been a long time since I've read this book, I vaguely remember it, but I remember enjoying it. Maybe I'll read it again. I had no idea it was part of a series. Or maybe I did and I forgot that I did.
Posted on: 2008/9/4 7:54
|
|||||||||||
|
_________________
Following the wind to places unknown..
|
|||||||||||
| Re: Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #4 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
Its definetely Simon.I read it some time back.I don't remember a few things about this book..
Posted on: 2008/9/4 10:15
|
|||||||||||
|
_________________
Shoujo Maniac
|
|||||||||||
| Re: Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #5 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
This is actually in my opinion the weakest book of the series. The second and fourth books actually were Newberry Award Honor/Winner books and the plot gets much more interesting later. This is sort of the intro book which sets the premise, but doesn't get too deeply into the actual good/bad conflict and motivations.
It is pretty derivative of C.S. Lewis' The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe aside from the King Arthur elements. The rest of the series is actually much more inventive. I actually remember the later books as rather scary or dark (it's been a long time since I read the other ones). The Arthurian ideas are really rather good. The figure of Great-Uncle Merry is my favorite. I love scholarly figures and he, of course, is the most in touch with what is really going on in the story. This book makes him a bit of a secondary character and a little "Indian Jones-like", but since it pre-dates the movie, maybe it's the movie which is derivative .
Posted on: 2008/9/4 11:10
|
|||||||||||
| Re: Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #6 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
Once I finally got around to reading the book, it only took me two or three days. I liked it very much!
I'd have to say my favorite character is Jane, just because I can relate to a lot of her theories and ideas. xD Does that sound odd? Ohh, thanks for that bit of info, ljspence. ^^ I think I'll have to see if my library has more of the books from that series. It sounds like a series I'd be interested in. ![]() I think I really liked the book because I'm really into mythology and stories like that. I've always liked the stories of King Arthur, and this book really painted a good picture of how things may have turned out in that situation. I also like Gumerry. He was a great character! So enigmatic! He sort of reminds me of someone... but I can't put my finger on it. >.> And, referring to the discussion starters, I probably would've done exactly what Simon, Jane, and Barney did. Maybe not if Great Uncle Merry wasn't there, but you get my point. I generally like dealing with things on my own, oddly enough. All in all, it was a good book and I definitely wouldn't mind reading the next book in the series, eh? ^^
Posted on: 2008/9/5 20:45
|
|||||||||||
| Re: Book Club Discussion: Over Sea, Under Stone | #7 | ||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
I just recently received the book from the library and was impressed with the way the author incorporated the ideas of the Arthurian lengends with a 'modern' family vacation.
Each character seemed to have some chractaristics people associate with the heroes and knights of those times. I think reading the rest of the series should be enjoyable.
Posted on: 2008/9/14 14:19
|
|||||||||||
|
_________________
![]() |
|||||||||||
![]() |
Register To Post |
You can view topic.
You cannot start a new topic.
You cannot reply to posts.
You cannot edit your posts.
You cannot delete your posts.
You cannot add new polls.
You cannot vote in polls.
You cannot attach files to posts.
You cannot post without approval.



All Games
RPG
Adventure
SIM
Story
Cute
Game Kits
Amaranth Games (games only by us)





















.














